top of page

For informational and educational purposes only - not personalized investment advice. Nothing here should be relied upon to make investment decisions. All investments involve risk, including possible loss of principal, and past performance does not guarantee future results. References to specific securities or market indicators are illustrative only and not a recommendation. Opinions are as of publication date and subject to change.

Are the Bulls Or Bears In Control? Depends On the Market.

Writer: Chris Kline
Chris Kline
1 day ago
3 min read

1.) BEARS - There are times when some markets fall into a bearish trend mode and others do not. We're in that cycle right now. Our definition of "bear market" isn't based on some subjective number like -20% down that you hear on CNBC. That's silly to call a bear market based on a number someone pulled out of a hat. Our definition is based on multiple factors. It's a range created by the rate of change of price, volume and volatility over a specified time series. For a trend to break, it's time series must be greater than 3 months. From there, you can track any sector and any index to give you some perspective of who's in control. Using our definition of bearish trend level, the Nasdaq fell below bearish trend levels on Oct 29, and failed at that level on Nov 4. That was the 5th day below the low end of trend. So what did that mean? Just that the Nasdaq's near-term action was being "controlled" by the bears. So far that has not changed and the index needs to get back above 26,330 to change the trend. The tech sector in general, tracked by XLK, is about the same. Fell into bear trend on Oct 30, failed on Nov 4 and remains below trend. XLK needs to get back above 186 to change that. How about the all important semiconductor sector? The VanEck Semi fund - SMH - is a good tracking fund for that sector. It's been in and out of bearish territory since failing on July 31 with a brief fake-out at the end of Sept / beginning of Oct. Nov 5. That had some markings of capitulation for semis...but not really enough to turn the tide. I wrote about the Nasdaq on Nov 4 and if that was the bottom. It still may be, but that index may also need to sweep the summer lows to scare enough people out at exactly the wrong time. Capitulation.

Meanwhile, the S&P 500 is still above its bearish trend level. So, we've got semiconductors and Tech (broadly) in a bear market with the S&P 500 not really flinching. If we look back, in the five prior episodes since 2011 where SMH was down 25%+ and XLK 15%+ from their 52-week highs, SPY (S&P 500 tracking fund) was already in a double-digit drawdown every time. Today it's down just -3%. That's showing some strength.

DailyChartbook infographic with three line charts comparing SPY, XLK, and SMH drawdowns; headline says chips in a bear market.

2.) TOP VS BOTTOM - The valuation premium of the largest US companies has narrowed...now the tightest in almost 10 years. The valuation premium of the largest US companies (mainly the mega-cap tech names such as the Magnificent Seven) is the extra amount investors have been willing to pay for them versus the rest of the market—typically measured by higher price-to-earnings ratios. This has happened mainly because their earnings have grown very strongly (driven by AI-related demand and investment), compressing their multiples even as prices held up or rose, while the broader market has not seen the same earnings surge. Bottom line is that while mega-cap tech, like the MAG 7, are flirting with bearish trends, this tightened valuation premium has made those stocks relatively cheaper versus the rest of the market than at any point in nearly a decade. Can they get even cheaper? Yep. Will they? Depends on macro factors. If we see growth and inflation slowing more together, then the potential for them to get cheaper goes up. Right now, the macro picture is pointing more toward a 1st half of 2027 slowdown, which the market might be pulling forward now. 

Line chart titled Exhibit 13 showing S&P 500 12m forward P/E for top 5 stocks vs other 495, with the premium narrowing since 2020

3.) GROWTH - I just mentioned the likely slowdown in growth in the 1st half of next year. So the question is whether we have finally reached peak earnings growth. No one knows for sure, but it's starting to look that way. The next 12 month's earnings estimate is up 39% from a year ago (blue shaded area) but is starting to look toppy against an expected growth rate of 19% over the next 12 months (green shaded area). The base effect is kicking in. In other words, current and forward earnings are getting tougher and tougher to accelerate past the previous quarter and year. Even though earnings might beat estimates, the market takes its cues from an acceleration or deceleration from those base effects. And what looks like is headed toward the market is a deceleration from that base effect. That is slowing growth. Numbers are good...but they're having a harder and harder time getting past the base effects. That sets up the increasing potential for markets that want to trade sideways to down.


Fidelity chart of S&P 500 earnings and valuation, with blue/yellow area graph and note: EPS is growing but now decelerating.

 
 

References to model portfolios reflect proprietary model activity and do not represent any individual client account. Client portfolios may differ based on objectives, risk tolerance, tax considerations, and other factors. Model results do not guarantee individual performance.

Capstone Wealth Management Logo

© 2026 Capstone Wealth Management Corp. · SEC-Registered Investment Adviser

Capstone Wealth Management Corp. is an SEC-registered investment adviser. Registration does not imply a particular level of skill or training. This site is informational only and is not personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Past performance does not guarantee future results. See our Form ADV for full details on services, fees, and conflicts of interest.

bottom of page